aiqbench analysis
This theoretical study derives spinor structure directly from relativistic phase-space constraints, suggesting a classical origin for quantum spin without requiring intrinsic quantum postulates. By enforcing a specific mass-shell factorization, the authors demonstrate how Clifford algebras naturally emerge to describe relativistic transport and coherences. The work offers a rigorous mathematical bridge between classical mechanics and quantum phenomena, potentially reshaping foundational understandings of spin in high-energy physics.
Spinor Structure from Relativistic Mass-Shell Factorisation in Phase Space
arXiv:2608.29353v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Spin is usually regarded as one of the most intrinsically quantum phenomena, while its lack of a natural analogue in classical physics presents an obstacle to phase-space deformation-quantisation accounts of its origin. We show that this difficulty may arise from imposing an overly restrictive scalar Hamiltonian structure on relativistic phase space. Requiring the complete massive mass-shell constraint to be represented by a single finite-dimensional expression that is linear in all four components of momentum forces its coefficient matrices to satisfy a Clifford algebra. The minimal complex representation of this algebra is four-dimensional. Requiring statistical completeness within the rank-two subspace selected by the mass-shell factor then leads to a four-by-four matrix-valued ensemble distribution. At each on-shell momentum, the linear mass-shell operator selects a two-dimensional subspace, so a general classical ensemble is described by a $2 \times 2$ matrix before quantisation. Projecting the Weyl-ordered Liouville equation into this subspace gives relativistic transport while preserving arbitrary populations and coherences and the remaining projector components determine the first deformation correction. Expansion of the matrix Moyal star commutator yields the symmetrised classical matrix Liouvillian at leading order. If the stronger two-sided star constraints are imposed, they reproduce the left and right Dirac-Wigner equations and introduce $\hbar$ as the scale converting the dimensionless internal algebra into physical angular momentum. These results suggest a non-quantum origin for spinor structure and a route to reconciling relativistic covariance, classical phase-space transport, and quantum spin.
Abstract:Spin is usually regarded as one of the most intrinsically quantum phenomena, while its lack of a natural analogue in classical physics presents an obstacle to phase-space deformation-quantisation accounts of its origin. We show that this difficulty may arise from imposing an overly restrictive scalar Hamiltonian structure on relativistic phase space. Requiring the complete massive mass-shell constraint to be represented by a single finite-dimensional expression that is linear in all four components of momentum forces its coefficient matrices to satisfy a Clifford algebra. The minimal complex representation of this algebra is four-dimensional. Requiring statistical completeness within the rank-two subspace selected by the mass-shell factor then leads to a four-by-four matrix-valued ensemble distribution. At each on-shell momentum, the linear mass-shell operator selects a two-dimensional subspace, so a general classical ensemble is described by a $2 \times 2$ matrix before quantisation. Projecting the Weyl-ordered Liouville equation into this subspace gives relativistic transport while preserving arbitrary populations and coherences and the remaining projector components determine the first deformation correction. Expansion of the matrix Moyal star commutator yields the symmetrised classical matrix Liouvillian at leading order. If the stronger two-sided star constraints are imposed, they reproduce the left and right Dirac-Wigner equations and introduce $\hbar$ as the scale converting the dimensionless internal algebra into physical angular momentum. These results suggest a non-quantum origin for spinor structure and a route to reconciling relativistic covariance, classical phase-space transport, and quantum spin.
6 pages. A improved distinct, self-contained treatment of the free-particle result embedded in the broader framework of arXiv:2505.03551. It substantially revises and isolates the minimal argument for the Clifford algebra and rank-two spinor structure, responding to feedback that the result required a more focused presentation. The earlier preprint has broader scope and is not superseded
Quantum Physics (quant-ph); Classical Physics (physics.class-ph)
arXiv:2608.29353 [quant-ph]
(or arXiv:2608.29353v1 [quant-ph] for this version)
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2608.29353 arXiv-issued DOI via DataCite (pending registration)
Full text under the publisher's open licence · 311 words
Related coverage
On the relation between perspective-neutral, algebraic, and effective quantum reference frames
Quantum Journal · Aug 20, 2026
Multicomponent anyons in one-dimensional optical lattices
arXiv · Sep 30, 2026
Relativistic generalization of Feynman's path integral on the basis of extended Lagrangians
arXiv · Oct 15, 2026
Mass Dependence of Araki Relative Entropy through Modular Theory
arXiv · Sep 14, 2026