aiqbench analysis
This research establishes a method for semi-device-independent certification of incompatible quantum instruments using three-party communication tasks, marking a specific advancement in understanding quantum nonclassicality. By deriving tight bounds on classical performance, the study demonstrates that violating these limits serves as genuine proof of quantum advantage in communication protocols. The work deepens the theoretical framework for utilizing complex quantum dynamics beyond simple measurements or channels.
Genuine certification of incompatible quantum instruments through sequential communication tasks
arXiv:2606.23647v2 Announce Type: replace Abstract: Quantum instruments constitute the general description of quantum dynamics, encompassing both quantum measurements and quantum channels as special cases. Consequently, the incompatibility of quantum instruments represents a fundamental manifestation of nonclassicality in quantum theory. Here, we establish the operational significance of this notion by demonstrating communication tasks with classical inputs and outputs that enable the semi-device-independent certification of incompatible quantum instruments. We introduce a class of three-party communication tasks involving a sender, a relayer, and a receiver, and derive the tight upper bounds of the figure of merits of these tasks achievable by all compatible instruments implemented by the relayer. Furthermore, we show that these bounds coincide with the optimal performance attainable in a classical communication subject to the same dimensional constraints. Violation of this bound certifies the incompatibility of the pair of quantum instruments implemented by the relayer. This identifies certification of incompatible instruments as a manifestation of quantum advantage in communication. This certification protocol is genuine as it is able to certify the incompatibility of a pair of instruments where the set of induced measurements and the set of induced channels are compatible and, therefore it does not depend on the incompability of measurements and channels induced by the instruments. Finally, we identify the simplest instance of our communication scenario that enable the certification of incompatible quantum instruments.
Abstract:Quantum instruments constitute the general description of quantum dynamics, encompassing both quantum measurements and quantum channels as special cases. Consequently, the incompatibility of quantum instruments represents a fundamental manifestation of nonclassicality in quantum theory. Here, we establish the operational significance of this notion by demonstrating communication tasks with classical inputs and outputs that enable the semi-device-independent certification of incompatible quantum instruments. We introduce a class of three-party communication tasks involving a sender, a relayer, and a receiver, and derive the tight upper bounds of the figure of merits of these tasks achievable by all compatible instruments implemented by the relayer. Furthermore, we show that these bounds coincide with the optimal performance attainable in a classical communication subject to the same dimensional constraints. Violation of this bound certifies the incompatibility of the pair of quantum instruments implemented by the relayer. This identifies certification of incompatible instruments as a manifestation of quantum advantage in communication. This certification protocol is genuine as it is able to certify the incompatibility of a pair of instruments where the set of induced measurements and the set of induced channels are compatible and, therefore it does not depend on the incompability of measurements and channels induced by the instruments. Finally, we identify the simplest instance of our communication scenario that enable the certification of incompatible quantum instruments.
arXiv:2606.23647 [quant-ph]
(or arXiv:2606.23647v2 [quant-ph] for this version)
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2606.23647 Focus to learn more arXiv-issued DOI via DataCite
arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website.
Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them.
Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs.
Full text under the publisher's open licence · 309 words
Related coverage

Strict hierarchy between $n$-wise measurement simulability, compatibility structures, and multi-copy compatibility
Quantum Journal · Oct 8, 2026

Quantum Advantages Cannot Be Faked by Simple Measurements, Research Confirms
Quantum Zeitgeist · Jun 12, 2026

Quantifiers and witnesses for the nonclassicality of measurements and of states
Quantum Journal · Jul 30, 2026
Topology-independent quantum advantage in communication networks
arXiv · Oct 6, 2026