aiqbench analysis
This research addresses the critical issue of catastrophic forgetting in continual learning by deriving an exact operator framework that links task distribution structure to performance decay. The study demonstrates how subsequent tasks can collectively enable recovery without revisiting specific past data, offering theoretical guarantees for maintaining knowledge in dynamic environments. These findings provide a rigorous mathematical foundation for designing more robust sequential learning systems that adapt to evolving data streams.
From Order to Distribution: An Exact Operator Framework for Forgetting in Continual Learning
arXiv:2604.13460v2 Announce Type: replace-cross Abstract: A central challenge in continual learning is forgetting: the loss of performance on previously learned tasks after learning new ones. Prior theory has analyzed forgetting under random orderings of fixed task collections in overparameterized linear regression. We shift the focus from task order to task distribution, asking how its structure determines forgetting. In the linear setting with a shared solution, i.i.d. task sampling, and sequential exact fitting, we derive an exact operator identity expressing historical forgetting directly in terms of the task distribution. Building on this identity, we establish an exponential decay guarantee for expected historical forgetting under every fixed task distribution in finite dimensions, characterize its asymptotic behavior, and relate decay to the distribution's coverage of observable directions. For an individual learned task, we show that subsequent tasks can collectively support recovery without exact revisits. We derive a lower bound on recovery time and construct a task distribution attaining its inverse-coverage scaling.
Abstract:A central challenge in continual learning is forgetting: the loss of performance on previously learned tasks after learning new ones. Prior theory has analyzed forgetting under random orderings of fixed task collections in overparameterized linear regression. We shift the focus from task order to task distribution, asking how its structure determines forgetting. In the linear setting with a shared solution, i.i.d. task sampling, and sequential exact fitting, we derive an exact operator identity expressing historical forgetting directly in terms of the task distribution. Building on this identity, we establish an exponential decay guarantee for expected historical forgetting under every fixed task distribution in finite dimensions, characterize its asymptotic behavior, and relate decay to the distribution's coverage of observable directions. For an individual learned task, we show that subsequent tasks can collectively support recovery without exact revisits. We derive a lower bound on recovery time and construct a task distribution attaining its inverse-coverage scaling.
34 pages, 3 figures. Revised analysis and proofs; new fixed-operator comparisons and recovery results
Machine Learning (cs.LG); Artificial Intelligence (cs.AI)
arXiv:2604.13460 [cs.LG]
(or arXiv:2604.13460v2 [cs.LG] for this version)
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2604.13460 Focus to learn more arXiv-issued DOI via DataCite
reproducibility/image-main/A.npy
reproducibility/image-main/D.npy
reproducibility/image-main/F.npy
reproducibility/image-main/K.npy
reproducibility/image-main/README.md
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s0_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s0_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s1_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s1_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s2_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s2_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s3_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s3_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s4_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s4_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/cifar10_split_features_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/direct64.npy
reproducibility/image-main/lambda_.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.json
reproducibility/image-main/mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-main/plot_images.py
reproducibility/image-main/x.npy
reproducibility/image-study/README.md
reproducibility/image-study/check_saved_results.py
reproducibility/image-study/curves.json
reproducibility/image-study/effect-summary.csv
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_features_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s5_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s5_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s6_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s6_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s7_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s7_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s8_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s8_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s9_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar100_split_other_replication_s9_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_features_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s5_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s5_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s6_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s6_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s7_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s7_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s8_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s8_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s9_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_cifar10_split_other_replication_s9_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s5_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s5_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s6_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s6_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s7_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s7_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s8_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s8_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s9_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s9_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s5_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s5_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s6_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s6_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s7_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s7_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s8_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s8_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s9_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s9_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s5_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s5_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s6_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s6_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s7_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s7_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s8_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s8_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s9_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s9_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_features_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s5_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s5_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s6_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s6_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s7_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s7_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s8_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s8_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s9_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s9_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_features_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s0_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s0_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s1_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s1_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s2_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s2_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s3_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s3_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s4_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s4_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s5_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s5_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s6_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s6_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s7_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s7_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s8_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s8_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s9_random.npy
reproducibility/image-study/larger_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s9_semantic.npy
reproducibility/image-study/paired-effects.csv
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_features_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar100_split_other_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_features_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_cifar10_split_other_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_permuted_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot4_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_rot60_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_features_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_mnist_split_mnist_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_features_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s0_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s0_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s0_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s0_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s1_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s1_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s1_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s1_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s2_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s2_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s2_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s2_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s3_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s3_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s3_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s3_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s4_random_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s4_random_n8.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s4_semantic_n3.npy
reproducibility/image-study/primary_yearbook_temporal_other_replication_s4_semantic_n8.npy
reproducibility/recovery/README.md
reproducibility/recovery/check_recovery_bounds.py
reproducibility/recovery/recovery_verification.json
(473 additional files not shown) You must enabled JavaScript to view entire file list.
arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website.
Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them.
Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs.
Full text under the publisher's open licence · 753 words
Related coverage

Microsoft’s AI chief says superintelligence is near, but won’t take your job
The Verge · Jun 8, 2026

It’s about ethics in journalism, with Ben Smith
The Verge · Aug 17, 2026

Presentation: From Hype to Strong Foundations: What the Rise, Fall and Resurgence of Agents Can Teach Us About Outlasting the Cycle
InfoQ · Jun 17, 2026

Tariffs didn’t bring manufacturing jobs back to the US
The Verge · Jul 27, 2026